• Home
  • Memories Yaccked
  • Brief Yacck
  • About Yacck
  • How does it work?
  • Contact Us
  • Who is this??
  • Mort's Memories

Welcome to YACCK
Where Memories remain

Google search for what you are looking for in the search box below... 

Welcome to Yacck - we hope you have great pleasure in reading the stories from the past and would love you to make positive comments for everyone to enjoy. The Yacck Team.

Southland v Canterbury 1946 - Ranfurly Shield Challenge

5/31/2016

5 Comments

 
Picture
It is 1946 and Southland played Canterbury on Saturday 24 August 1946.  The curtain raisers were Balfour v Mossburn and Collegiate v Old Boys (2nd Grade).
Mick Pittaway (21 games) and G. Cameron (19 games) for Southland.

Picture
The teams were:  
Southland:  T.R. Webster, R. Grenfell, A. Chandler, A. G. Sutherland, N.J. Bennett, R. F. Waldron, E.D. Calder, G. Spittle, G. Cameron, J. A. McRae, A. Budd, D. Brown, S. R. Pittaway, R. Hazlett, J. Stuck, H. Sandri, H. Hammond, R. Campbell, W. Stewart, R. Cody, J. Cameron, E. G. Walker.
Canterbury:
P. Callanan, W. Argus, W. McHugh, R.Thomson, P. Kearney, J. Roach, R. Monigatti, G. Bond, P.K. Rhind, A. Lee, R. Duff, K. Bain, D. Herman, F. Hobbs, M. Henderson, E. Lucre, P. Vincent, P. Gilmour, J. Carroll.

It was reported:
In the second challenge match of the season between Canterbury and Southland, Canterbury will be having their first tilt at the Shield since they were defeated by Otago in 1938.
Canterbury's record in Ranfurly Shield games was good in having won the shield three times from defenders, Manawhenua in 1927, Wellington in 1931 and Auckland in 1935.  In all they had won 23 games.
Southland and Canterbury had last met in Christchurch in 1939, just on the eve of the outbreak of the war.  Unbeaten at the time, Southland had a hard job to beat the Red and Blacks who just went under by 10 points to 8.
R. L. Roberts and J.J. McAuliffe scored tried for Canterbury and Jim Ballantyne (former Southland full back) converted one.  Southland's points came from a try by R. G. Mahony, a dropped goal by M. P. Grace and a penalty goal by A. W. Wesney.
Invercargill last had a visit from Canterbury in 1938.  That match was to have been a Shield game, but Otago got in first and took the trophy away to Dunedin. Southland defeated Canterbury that season by 9 points to nil - three goals kicked by Jim Ballantyne.
Southland and Canterbury had taken part as opponents in only two Ranfurly Shield games, both at Christchurch.  In 1933, when 1000 or more enthusiastic Southlanders made an all-night train journey to Christchurch to see Southland play, Canterbury won by 21 to 3 and two years later Canterbury again defeated Southland by 8 points to 3.  Was there mud and slush on Lancaster Park that day? The game was played in the worst conditions imaginable.
It was anticipated that Canterbury's 1946 challenge would be strong and six of the team played for the South Island at Wellington the previous Saturday.  Three of their team were All Blacks in W. G. Argus, J. G. Bond and P.K. Rhind.
Thirty eight games had been played between the North and South Island teams by 1946 with North having won 20 and South 15 and three of them drawn.


Mossburn V Balfour - Curtain-raiser

The teams were:
Mossburn:  A. Sutherland, J. Feeley, V. Chewings, R. Carston, R. Carter, R. Shaw, R. King, M. Cournane, W. Carran, G. Kirker, F. Cournane, C. Boyd, J. Riorden, W. Cooper, A. Carran. G. Grey, M. McCorkindale, B. Hamilton, P. Alchrist.
Balfour:  F. Proctor, H. Stevens, D. McLean, W. Stewart, A. Stewart, R. Gillespie, W. Cooper, D. Gillespie, T. Cahill, W. Rutter, R. Stewart, J. Stevens, B. Watson, C. Stevens, D. McGregor, M Orr, F. Hailes, S. Grant, J. Robb.

This game was of great interest due to these two senior teams having played the previous week.  The game ended in a scoreless draw and this game was the play off for the Northern Sub-Union championship.



Picture
PictureT.R.D. Webster kicking the first of his three goals.
Southland was successful in their defence of the Ranfurly Shield in 1946 before a crowd of 9-10,000.
Webster was brillant at full back for Southland and was well supported by Argus who had scintillating runs and the power of G. Cameron the front row forward.
Although the lighter Southland pack took a battering in the rucks and lineouts (21-9) it did not deter them from taking full advantage of the dry conditions and had good breaks which got their backs on to the front foot.
The Canterbury forwards were ferocious and more often than not used dubious tactics to try and upset the Southlanders. The crowd let the Red and Black know that they were not happy with some of their incidents and especially one, where they injured Webster when he was going down on the ball.  Webster spoke with his boot though and carved of territory with accurate line kicking.
Argus was impressive for Canterbury and showed his pace on more than one occasion.  He was a class three quarter and would have been wanted for the South African tour.
​

Picture
5 Comments
Rugby Watcher
5/31/2016 07:51:40 pm

Without a doubt the most talked about rugby man in Invercargill was Tom Webster. After his magnificent display on Saturday 24th August 1946 he showed himself to be a full back of class.
He gained the form which gave him a place in the North Island side while playing for Wellington in 1941.
The Canterbury full-back, P. Calanan, who had represented the South Island team was outclassed by Webster in every aspect of the game.
His display seen on Rugby Park was one of the finest ever seen.

Reply
A Budd
5/31/2016 08:23:56 pm

I see the above comment and also want to say that Alf Budd was also outstanding and played excellent rugby in 1946,
One sport reporter had predicted greater things for Budd and had chosen him to represent New Zealand against Australia as a lock.

Reply
Yacck
5/31/2016 08:28:52 pm

Budd was a special player who played for Bluff and had 53 games for Southland between 1946 and 1952. I see there was an A.E. Budd that played for Bluff and also Southland 1918-19, 1921 nine times. I wonder was this his father??

Reply
yacck
5/31/2016 08:31:24 pm

Approx 1940's Southland felt there was a lot of pressure to match the big provinces in producing great locks. Two men who answered their calls was Alf Budd and Dave Brown. They won respect for their strength and Budd stayed playing club and provincial rugby where he dominated lineouts and play in the tight for several seasons. He was one of the key men in the Bluff team and was given All Black honours for 1946 to 1949.

supporter
6/2/2016 03:51:13 pm

There is a good obituary about Mick Pittaway.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/southland-times/news/obituaries/4225513/Committed-to-NZ-rugby

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

This End User License Agreement (“Agreement”) is between you and Yacck and governs use of this app made available through the Apple App Store. By installing the Yacck App, you agree to be bound by this Agreement and understand that there is no tolerance for objectionable content. If you do not agree with the terms and conditions of this Agreement, you are not entitled to use the Yacck App.
  • Home
  • Memories Yaccked
  • Brief Yacck
  • About Yacck
  • How does it work?
  • Contact Us
  • Who is this??
  • Mort's Memories